Democratic Schools:
I think this
method of education is a great way to prepare the students to live in a
democratic society, but for me the benefits end there. I think children need boundaries and
democratic schools definitely lack in this area. I question whether the younger students are
mature enough to make the decisions that are expected of them. I do agree with the quote, “Young kids learn
from older kids.” This is definitely a
plus in any philosophy. I see this on a
daily basis in my mixed age group class.
Technology could be brought into the classroom to allow students to act
as tutors for their younger peers. I
would not put my child in a democratic school for the reasons listed
above.
Montessori:
I think
Montessori schools have their benefits and their drawbacks. They differ from traditional education in the
fact that they are more student-centered with hands-on learning. The students have more choices and are
expected to be more independent. I
think children who are intrinsically motivated will do much better in a
Montessori classroom.
Montessori
schools believe that “play is a child’s work”.
I strongly believe this and fully support it in my preschool
classroom. Montessori enhances social
development. I do like the idea of
mixed-age groups. I think this is a
benefit to everyone, older and younger students. Montessori teachers go through training and
certification in the practice.
Like Montessori schools, traditional
schools also have hands-on activities but to a lesser degree. I think children need teacher directed
activities throughout the day. They need
to learn to follow directions in order to grow as an individual. I would not choose to send my child to a
Montessori school.
Glen Urquhart School:
The
first thing that impressed me when I took the online tour of GUS was the
spacious, bright classrooms and the beautiful outdoor surroundings. It is a beautiful campus with so much to
offer. GUS combines traditional learning
with a more progressive approach. Education
is student-centered. GUS aims to build a
community among the students in their school.
I like the quote “We are preparing students to change the world.” I was not able to access the tuition
rates. I kept getting an error
message. I am guessing tuition at the
Glen Urquhart School is not cheap. I
think the concept is great but I don’t think it is very accessible to lower
income families.
Waldorf Education:
Imaginative
play plays an important part of a child’s early development in the Waldorf
Model. Learning is hands-on. Children
take an active role in their own education.
Most schools are based on Christian beliefs. The teacher’s main role in the Waldorf models
seems to be that of role-model. The
Waldorf approach breaks a child’s development into seven year increments.
I
did a little more internet research on this model on my own. One website describes Waldorf Education as
being threefold: thinking, feeling and doing.
I like the fact that Waldorf is very-hands on, but again I think
children need certain boundaries in order to learn and function. They need guidelines and teachers
directions.
Some of the drawbacks that I see
with this model are:
·
Students have the same teacher for several
years.
·
Technology is very scarce.
·
Textbooks are not used.
·
Boundaries are limited.
·
There is a lack of testing.
·
There is a religious affiliation which is not
alright with everyone.
·
A Waldorf education can be expensive.
Flipped Classroom:
The teachers main role in a
flipped classroom is that of a mentor/coach.
Of all the models we read about this is definitely the one that allows
for the use of technology. Students need
to be able to access the internet in order to do their work and research. Instead of in class lectures, class time is
spent on class discussions, problems and group projects.
Students are
held accountable for meeting deadlines. They
need to be self-motivated and self-starters.
This is not the model for every student. Not all students have access to
the same technology at home which can pose a problem for some students.
Pedagogy of the Oppressed:
This
was the last article I read and it completely confused me. I feel like I walked away without an
understanding of this model (even after doing my own research).